What do I look for in a good quality Puerh?
Sheng / Raw Puerh
Good quality sheng Puerh should be pleasant to drink, even when young, and not exhibit excessively harsh flavors such as bitterness, smokiness or astringency. Look for cakes with whole, well-preserved leaf material that is not chopped.
- Soup that is free of broken bits or charred particles, with good clarity and a bright radiant color (汤色亮)
- Aroma from the gaiwan lid should be rich, sweet/savory without any harsh, smoky or sulphuric odors
- The soup should not be overly fragrant when sniffing; instead, the fragrance should be held within the soup and experienced only during sipping in the mouth and throat. This is known in Chinese as 落汤香
- Smooth, velvety soup texture. It should glide down the throat when swallowing without a puckering effect. This is described as the “path of the soup is wide” (水路宽)
- Excessive bitterness and/or astringency is a sign of poor quality or material selection – it is a myth that young sheng is hard to enjoy
- Well-processed material from older trees should be persistent across many brews. Flavor profile should not exhibit sudden drops in intensity or richness between brews, but instead slowly evolve across the session.
Shou
The dry leaf should smell fragrant and rich, like sweet wood or clean leather. A good shou Puerh will yield a thick, smooth soup that is lubricative and not rough/tannic. Sometimes the character of stewed red beans or a “rice water” profile is sought after by Chinese enthusiasts.
Avoid aged teas that smell papery, cardboardy or musty – these odors are an indication of poor storage.
Fishiness and mushroomy odors are associated with the wet-pile fermentation or “wo dui” process, and may dissipate slowly with age.
Good shou Puerh however, should not exhibit excessive wet-pile odor even when young, as this is an indication of improper fermentation methods from the
start.